|
|
||||||||

* Geron Corporation, Menlo Park, California 94025, USA, and
Department of Pathology, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195, USA
1Correspondence: Geron Corporation, 230 Constitution Drive, Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA. E-mail: dchoi{at}geron.com
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words:
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5'-helicase activity (7)
5'-exonuclease activity (8
The means by which the biochemical deficiencies resulting from WRN
mutations are translated into the pathophysiology of the syndrome are
not yet defined. WRN cells display genomic instability and a mutator
phenotype, resulting in an increased frequency of variegated
chromosomal abnormalities (14
15
16)
. Sensitivity to DNA
damage induced by treatment with chemicals such as
4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide has been reported (17)
, although
UV repair mechanisms appear normal in WRN cells (18)
,
suggesting that deficiencies in DNA maintenance are selective. A
hallmark cellular phenotype of WRN fibroblasts is a reduced replicative
potential compared with age-matched controls (19)
. As in
normal fibroblasts cultured in vitro, telomeres shorten with
replicative passage, although the absolute length of telomeres in
senescent WRN cultures has been reported to be longer than that seen in
senescent cultures of normal cells, suggesting that senescence in WRN
cells may be induced by effectors other than shortened telomeres
(20)
. The parallels seen between accelerated tissue aging
in WRN patients with accelerated in vitro aging of derived
cells indicate that replicative senescence may play an important role
in WRN pathologies. Recent studies have documented the immortalization
of WRN fibroblast strains by the expression of an hTERT
transgene (21
, 22)
. In this study, we have examined the
gene expression patterns observed in early- and late-passage cultures
of WRN fibroblasts and contrasted these with derivative cultures that
express a telomerase transgene.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
WRN transcript sequence analysis
RNA from cell strain AGO3141B was prepared as described earlier
(23)
. Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction
(RT-PCR) and DNA sequence analysis of the WRN transcript was performed
as previously described (24)
.
hTERT transduction
pBABE and pBABE-hTERT retroviral preparations were a kind
gift of Woodring Wright (University of Texas Medical Center at Dallas).
Actively growing WRN strains were infected with virus at PD 13
(AGO3141B), PD 8.9 (AGO0780G), and PD 13.5 (AGO5229B). Three days after
infection, cells were switched to selective medium containing 0.3
µg/ml puromycin.
Telomere length analysis
Mean telomere restriction fragment (TRF) lengths for WRN cell
cultures were determined by Southern blotting as described earlier
(25)
.
Senescence-associated ß-galactosidase (SAß-gal)
Assays were performed as previously described (26)
on WRN cell cultures cultured in DMEM plus 10% FBS.
Microarray analysis
The microarray system and methodologies used in this study
have been described previously (23)
. A complete
description of the composition and performance of this system can be
viewed at (http://www.geron.com/pubsupplement/wrn.html). All analyses
were performed under contract with Incyte Microarray Services (Fremont,
Calif.). Poly(A)+ mRNA was prepared from
subconfluent cultures using OligoTex cartridges (Qiagen, Valencia,
Calif.). The RNA was quantified by A260
measurements, assessed by agarose gel electorphoresis. Conversion of
mRNA into either a Cy5- or a Cy3-labeled cDNA probe and competitive
hybridizations of probes were performed substantially as described
earlier (27)
, and bound signal was quantified by
fluorescence measurement. Signals that scored with a signal to
background level <2.5 in both channels were not considered. The total
Cy5 signal across all elements was normalized to the total Cy3 signal,
and differential expression ratios were then calculated. Each
experimental pairing of mRNAs was performed in duplicate, and the
results present the average of the two measurements (see website for
details). Genes whose expression levels changed by a mean average of
2.5-fold or more are presented in this report. The identities of all
genes indicated in this report were confirmed by DNA sequence analysis
of the corresponding cDNAs.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
T homozygous alteration at the nucleotide 1339, which results
in the stop codon mutation at amino acid 389: CGA(Glu)
TGA(Stp)
(5)
T transition at nucleotide 2433, introducing a nonsense
codon at amino acid 748. This result was confirmed by the PCR
sequencing of the corresponding exon 19.
hTERT transduction
All three confirmed WRN strains showed typically abbreviated
replicative potential, with each displaying nearly complete growth
arrest by PD 2030 (Fig. 1
). Transduction of these strains with a control retrovirus did not alter
their replicative life span, but transduction with hTERT-expressing
retrovirus resulted in robust, exponential growth rates. Telomerase
activity assays (TRAP) indicated that all three hTERT-transduced lines
displayed abundant telomerase activity, whereas no activity was
observed in control or parental strains (data not shown). The
telomerase-expressing cultures showed continuous growth well past the
normal senescence point of the parental strains and showed no sign of
slowing or decrease for the duration of the study.
|
We next analyzed telomere lengths in two of the WRN strains and their
telomerase-expressing derivatives. Telomere lengths shortened with
replicative passage by
0.6 kbp and 1.6 kbp for strains AGO3141B and
AGO0780G, respectively (Fig. 2
). Our analyses did not include sufficient time points for these
cultures to be able to predict rates of shortening accurately; however,
the lengths of telomeres in these late-passage WRN strains did not
appear to be significantly different from those reported for normal
fibroblast strains (23
, 25
, 29)
. Telomere lengths in
hTERT-transduced AGO3141B cultures initially have similar TRF lengths
as PD length-matched control cultures, and only with additional
passaging did mean telomere lengths increase. In both hTERT-derived
strains, TRF lengths continued to increase, resulting in later stage
cultures with TRF lengths that were twice the length of the original
WRN parental cultures.
|
Gene expression patterns
As a preliminary assessment, we first analyzed the SAß-gal
activity of early- and late-passage WRN cells, and in hTERT-transduced
derivatives. As seen in Fig. 3
, SAß-gal activity was absent from both early-passage and
hTERT-transduced cultures of AGO0780G but was abundant in late-passage
nontransduced cultures. Similar results were obtained with the
equivalent groupings of cell strains AGO3141B and AGO5229B (data not
shown).
|
We previously described our development of a midscale cDNA microarray
and its application in studying senescence-associated gene expression
patterns in normal cell strains (23)
. This array surveys
1000 independent genes and samples most of the major signaling and
biochemical circuitries of human cells. Here, we used this same array
to assess differences in mRNA expression patterns in early- and
late-passage WRN lines and hTERT-expressing derivatives. All three
possible pairings for each of the cultures were performed (early
passage vs. late passage, early passage vs. hTERT expressing, late
passage vs. hTERT expressing), allowing us to cross-check the
consistency of the array system.
For initial consideration, we compared early and senescent passages of
WRN cultures (Fig. 4
, dark bars). The mRNA expression patterns induced at senescence in WRN
cells varied between independent cell strains and overlapped with those
observed in normal senescent human fibroblast strains. In particular,
senescence in WRN strains induced the expression of degradative
proteases such as stromelysin-1, stromelysin-2, collagenase, and
cathepsin O; immune and inflammatory response markers such as
intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1), monocyte chemoattractant
protein-1 (MCP-1), and interleukin 6 (IL-6); and growth factor
modulators such as insulin-like growth factor (IGF) binding proteins 2
and 5 and stanniocalcin. In addition to these markers of fibroblast
senescence, a pronounced induction of the mismatch repair homologue
PMS3 was seen in two of the three lines, along with the induction of a
SCG10, a homologue of the phosphoprotein stathmin. As well, senescence
in two of the three lines induced significant expression of
prostaglandin D synthase. mRNAs that were down-regulated by senescence
in WRN cells include matrix structural proteins, such as the collagens
and elastin, and hepatoma-derived growth factor. In one of the cell
strains, AGO5229B, we did not observe down-regulation of any genes
beyond our threshold cut-off of 2.5-fold.
|
A comparison of the expression of these same genes in hTERT-expressing
WRN cell derivatives is presented (Fig. 4
, white bars). For many of the
genes whose expression levels were increased at senescence, the overall
effect of hTERT expression was to maintain expression at levels
comparable to those seen in early-passage WRN cells. In two of the WRN
strains, AGO0780G and AGO5229B, the induction of high levels of matrix
proteases and inflammation-associated markers was prevented almost
completely by hTERT expression, and similar effects were seen for the
WRN-associated markers PMS3 and SCG10. For strain AGO3141B, the
prevention of senescence-associated gene expression was less complete,
and high levels of cathepsin O, rho8, and p18 persisted in
hTERT-expressing cells.
For genes whose expression is reduced at senescence, hTERT expression
had relatively little effect in preventing this process. For strain
AGO3141B, hTERT expression did not affect the down-regulation of genes
for structural proteins such as collagen IV, keratin 1 or 18, and
tenascin; similar results were seen in strain AGO0780G, in which hTERT
expression did not prevent the loss of expression of elastin and
collagens. In neither strain did hTERT expression prevent the
down-regulation at senescence of the gene for hepatoma-derived growth
factor, a gene also observed to be down-regulated in normal fibroblasts
at senescence (23)
.
A direct comparison of early-passage WRN cells with hTERT-derived
strains is presented in Table 1
and confirms the results observed for senescence-associated gene
expression patterns. For instance, hTERT-expressing AGO3141B cells
expressed higher levels of cathepsin O and decreased levels of
collagens compared with early-passage AGO3141B cells. These
comparisons reveal differences in expression in addition to those
associated with WRN senescence. Compared with hTERT-expressing
derivatives, early-passage AGO3141B cells overexpressed
inflammation-associated mRNAs, such as MCP-1, Gro-
, and IL-6, and
matrix-degrading stromelysin and tissue plasminogen activator.
Interestingly, early-passage AGO3141B cells also expressed higher
levels of a series of collagens and fibronectin than did
hTERT-derived cells. Inversely, hTERT-derived AGO3141B cells expressed
higher levels of a scattered variety of mRNAs, including transforming
growth factor ß receptor 3, PPAR receptor, and the hyaluronic acid
receptor CD44. Comparisons of AGO0780G cells showed higher levels of
stromelysin and elastin in early-passage cells than in hTERT-expressing
derivatives, whereas higher levels of the early serum response genes
EGRP1 and c-fos were seen in hTERT-derivatized cells.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The results from mRNA expression analysis of WRN cells at
senescence reinforce previous findings that the response of individual
cell strains varies significantly. Although all three WRN strains
investigated here arrest with similar morphologies and express a common
biochemical marker, SAß-gal activity, the cadre of markers induced by
senescence shares only partial overlap in the WRN lines. Similar
variability has been observed in the replicative capacity of WRN
strains, even among different strains developed from the same donor
sample (32)
. The overlap between senescence-induced
expression profiles of WRN cells with those of senescent cultures of
normal cells is substantial and has been predicted by previous studies
of WRN cultures (33)
. These include induced expression of
proinflammatory genes, matrix-degrading activities, and reduced
expression of matrix structural genes, all of which could contribute to
the associated pathologies of the syndrome.
The induction of a homologue of a DNA mismatch repair enzyme homologue
PMS3 seen in two of the WRN lines has not been reported for other
normal human cell strains at senescence and also appears to correlate
with the induced expression of SCG10, a homologue of the
signal-transducing protein stathmin. Whether these effects are linked
to the known mutator phenotype of WRN cells is unknown. Extracts from
WRN cells are deficient in mismatch repair activity (34)
,
and thus, the accumulation of chromosomal abnormalities observed in WRN
cells passaged in vitro may eventually result in the
induction of repair-associated activities. However, the induction of
both the PMS3 homologue and SCG10 is prevented by the expression of
telomerase, suggesting that telomeric effects, and not simply random
accumulation of DNA damage throughout the chromosome, contribute to the
induction of these two genes.
Premature replicative senescence is a defining phenotype of primary WRN
cells and thus the immortalization of these cells by telomerase has led
to the suggestion that telomerase may be useful in preventing
pathologies associated with the disease (21)
.
In all three WRN strains examined here, telomere expression prevented
the induction of only some of those genes associated with senescence.
In normal diploid fibroblasts, telomerase expression prevents the
induction of senescence-associated genes almost completely
(35)
. This difference in gene expression between
telomerized WRN and normal cell strains may reflect the unstable
genomic phenotype of WRN strains, because genes whose expression is
changing as a result of mutation, rather than as a result of a
senescence arrest, might not be affected by telomerase expression.
To what extent does telomerase affect other forms of molecular
pathology in WRN cells? WRN cells accumulate numerous forms of
chromosomal abnormalities, including translocations (15
, 36)
, deletions (37)
, and aneuploidy
(38)
. Karyotype analysis of early-passage (PD14) WRN
strain AGO0780G revealed substantial abnormality, including aneuploidy,
telomeric associations, and deletions. Telomerase expression had no
obvious effect on the disarranged karyotype of this strain, indicating
the preservation of the mutator phenotype in these immortalized
cultures (S. Pathak, W.D.F., unpublished results). Similar results have
also been reported for other telomerase-immortalized WRN strains,
indicating that fundamental molecular defects are preserved by
telomerization (22)
. In addition, the expression of
telomerase did not change the resistance of the same WRN strain toward
4-nitroquinoline (D. Shelton and W. D. F., unpublished
results), again suggesting that this susceptibility of WRN cells is not
related to replicative potential. In WRN cells expressing a wild-type
WRN transgene, sensitivity to 4-nitroquinoline was also not suppressed,
suggesting that certain pathologies of WRN cells are secondary to the
primary genetic mutation (39)
.
At present, there is little evidence to suggest which deficits in WRN cells are responsible for the associated pathologies of the syndrome, or the extent to which primary or secondary mutational effects contribute. For instance, karyotypic instability or increased susceptibility to DNA damage may contribute to the early-onset cancers observed in WRN patients, whereas a decreased replicative capacity and premature senescence may result in regenerative impairment and thus may contribute to skin aging or cardiovascular disease. Furthermore, accelerated telomere loss may also contribute to genetic instability and tumor progression, whereas telomere-independent mutational changes could exacerbate replicative senescence-associated changes in tissue degeneration. Our results here suggest that in addition to preventing early-onset replicative senescence, telomerase activation can prevent the induction of senescence-associated gene expression patterns in WRN cells but fails to prevent the phenotypic drift associated with long-term cultivation of WRN cells.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Received for publication March 16, 2000.
Revision received September 15, 2000.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5' exonuclease. Nat. Genet. 20,114-116[Medline]
5' DNA exonuclease. J. Biol. Chem. 273,34145-34150
3' exonuclease activity that digests DNA and RNA strands in DNA/DNA and RNA/DNA duplexes dependent on unwinding. Nucleic Acids Res 27,2361-2368
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |