|
|
||||||||

Department of Physiol., St. Georges Hospital Medical School, University of London, Tooting, SW17 0RE;
* University Laboratory of Physiol., Oxford, OX1 3PT; and
Academic Unit of Child Health, University of Manchester, Manchester, M13, U.K.
1Correspondence: Department of Physiology, St. Georges Hospital Medical School, University of London, Tooting, SW17 0RE, U.K. E-mail: jsgibson{at}sghms.ac.uk
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: oxygen potassium HbS HbA red cells
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The hydration state of HbS-containing red cells (here termed HbS cells)
is critical because the lag time to polymerization after deoxygenation
is inversely proportional to approximately the 30th power of [HbS]
(5)
. A small decrease in cell volume and a small increase
in [HbS], makes polymerization and SCC much more likely.
Unfortunately, the volume of HbS cells is very labile; they are prone
to rapid and irreversible shrinkage. Three membrane transporters,
quiescent or absent in HbA red cells but active in HbS cells,
contribute to dehydration: the
K+-Cl- cotransporter
(termed KCC and probably the KCC1 isoform) (6
7
8)
, the
Gardos channel (probably IK1) (9
10
11
12)
, and
Psickle (13
14
15
16
17)
. KCC mediates
coupled KCl efflux (18)
; the Gardos channel is a
Ca2+-activated K+ channel
(9)
, mediating conductive K+ efflux,
coupled electrically to Cl- efflux through
distinct Cl- channels or band 3;
Psickle is a cation-selective but fairly
nonspecific pathway that allows entry of Ca2+ (as
well as passage of other ions) (19)
, but whose molecular
identity remains obscure. The relative contribution of these pathways
to dehydration and sickling remains controversial (20
21
22
23
24)
and indeed may be variable. A thorough knowledge of their behavior is
required to understand the pathogenesis of SCD.
KCC activity in red cells is regulated by a number of physiological
factors (25)
. Well-established stimuli include cell
swelling (18
, 26)
, H+ ions
(27
, 28)
, and urea (29
30
31
32)
. In common with
many other red cell membrane transport systems (33
, 34)
,
it is also regulated by physiological O2 tensions
(PO2s). In normal human red cells
(termed HbA cells) and red cells from many other vertebrate species
(35
36
37
38
39)
, KCC is fully O2 dependent.
It is activated at high PO2s, whereas
at lower levels it is inactive and refractory to other stimuli. We have
shown that this requirement for O2 is lost in HbS
cells (39)
: the transporter remains active and stimulated
by swelling, H+ ions, and urea even in the
complete absence of O2.
The mechanism responsible for the different O2
dependence of KCC in HbA and HbS cells is not understood. HbS cells are
markedly heterogeneous and have a reduced life span (40
, 41)
. As suggested for other properties of sickle cells (see, for
example, refs 42
, 43
), the abnormal
O2 response may reside in a subpopulation of HbS
cells. It may result from their younger age. In addition,
polymerization of HbS at low PO2s is
an obvious difference. In the experiments described in this paper, HbS
and HbA cell samples were fractionated by density gradient
centrifugation and the substituted benzaldehyde 12C79 (44)
was used to increase the O2 affinity of HbS,
thereby altering the relationship between HbS saturation/polymerization
and PO2. For both series of
experiments, the effects on the O2 dependence of
KCC was investigated.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Solutions
The standard medium was MOPS-buffered saline (MBS) comprising
(in mM); NaCl (145), MOPS (10), glucose
(5), pH 7.4, at 37°C. MBS was nominally free of
Ca2+. To investigate the effects of
Cl- substitution, NaCl was replaced by equimolar
NaNO3. In some experiments pH was adjusted with
HNO3, giving pH 7 after addition of cells. These
salines had an osmolality of 290 mOsm.kg-1. In
experiments at pH 7 with HbA cells, osmolality was reduced to 260
mOsm.kg-1 by addition of distilled water. The
two stimuli were combined because HbA cells have a low KCC activity. To
investigate the effect of urea, stock solutions of 5 M urea were made
daily in the appropriate saline and diluted 10-fold to give a final
urea concentration of 500 mM.
Blood
Samples of normal (HbAA) and sickle (HbSS) red blood cells were
obtained with ethical permission by venepuncture of consenting
volunteers. Blood was collected in heparin-containing syringes and
stored at 4°C until needed (within 48 h). White cells were
removed by filtration through glass wool and red cells were then washed
3 times by centrifugation (2000 g; 5 min at 4°C) in MBS to
remove platelets and plasma. Discontinuous arabinogalactan gradients
were prepared as described by Ortiz et al. (45)
, with
densities 1.090 g/ml-1 and 1.100
g/ml-1 for HbS cells, and 1.087
g/ml-1, 1.089 g/ml-1 and
1.095 g/ml-1 for HbA cells, resting on a dense
cushion of 1.160 g/ml-1. Red cell samples were
layered on top of the gradients and centrifuged for 45 min at 52,000
g, 4°C. Cells were harvested from the top and bottom of
the gradients using a Pasteur pipette to yield low- and high-density
red cells, respectively. Contaminant arabinogalactan was removed by
washing 3 times in MBS (2000 g, 5 min at 4°C). The red
cells were then washed an additional 3 times in MBS ±
Cl- to achieve Cl-
substitution. Unfractionated controls were centrifuged and washed for
the same number of times, but were not exposed to the arabinogalactan
gradients.
Tonometry
Oxygen tension (PO2) was
controlled by incubating cells in Eschweiler tonometers coupled to a
Wösthoff gas mixing pump as described previously
(31)
. All experiments were carried out at 1 ATA.
PO2 was varied by replacement of
O2 with N2, and all gas
mixtures were fully saturated with water vapor at 37°C prior to
delivery to the tonometers. Blood samples in
Cl--free MBS were incubated at
40%
hematocrit for 15 min at each PO2
before influx measurement; control experiments showed that this
interval was adequate for complete equilibration. Samples were then
removed and diluted 10-fold into MBS (± Cl-)
containing urea (500 mM; pH 7.4), pH 7 (for HbS cells) or MBS 260
mOsm.kg-1 at pH 7 (for HbA cells),
pre-equilibrated to the same PO2, for
measurement of K+ influx. HbA cells were exposed
to both swelling and reduction in pH because these cells have a
relatively modest KCC activity. Radioisotope was added after 10 min to
allow sufficient time for pH stabilization or urea stimulation. To
measure O2 saturation, samples from the
tonometers were processed following the method of Tucker
(46)
. To assess sickling, other cell aliquots were taken
directly from tonometers and fixed in MBS with 1% glutaraldehyde
equilibrated at the same PO2 as the
tonometers. Percentage of sickled cells were then counted using an
hemocytometer.
12C79
Stock solutions of 12C79 (282 mM) were made daily in Tris base
(500 mM) and diluted in the appropriate saline to give a final
concentration of 5 mM. Cell samples at 40% hematocrit were incubated
with 12C79 (5 mM) in air for 15 min before placing them in tonometers
to adjust PO2. Measurement of both
O2 saturation and K+ influx
was made in the presence of 12C79 (5 mM).
Flux measurements
K+ influxes were determined at 37°C over
a 10 min period (during which uptake was linear). Although
K+ influx was measured, because of the outwardly
facing chemical gradient for K+ there would in
fact be a net loss of ions through the various K+
pathways; nevertheless, influx measurements indicate their activity
(18)
. 86Rb was used as a congener
added in KNO3 to give a final
K+ concentration of 7.5 mM (see ref
18
). Ouabain and bumetanide (100 µM) were present in all
experiments to inhibit the Na/K pump and NaK2Cl cotransporter,
respectively. The Cl--dependence of
K+ influx was taken as a measure of KCC activity
(Cl- substituted with
NO3-): in some cases, influxes
in both Cl- and
NO3- media are presented; in
others, for clarity, only the Cl--dependent flux
is given (calculated as the difference in influx ±
Cl-). Hematocrit was determined by optical
density using Drabkins solution (following the method of Beutler; see
refs 18
, 47
). K+ influxes are
expressed in standard units of mmol K+.(l
cells.h)-1.
Statistics
Results are presented as the mean ± SD for
single experiments, representative of at least 2 others, or as
mean ± SE for n experiments. Comparisons
were made using Students t test. For Fig. 4b
and Fig. 5b, c
, the lines of best fit were made by linear
regression using Sigmaplot (Jandel Scientific, Corte Madera, Calif.).
|
|
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
KCC activity in subpopulations of red cells
The pattern of K+ influxes was investigated
in subfractions of HbA and HbS cells after density gradient separation.
In all cases, K+ influx was greatest in the light
fraction and smallest in the dense fraction, with the
Cl--dependent component of
K+ influx responsible for most of this
difference. For HbS cells, combining results for stimulation by both
urea and H+ ions,
Cl--dependent K+ influx in
oxygenated low-density cells was 1.8 ± 0.2-fold greater than that
in unfractionated cells, whereas influx in the high-density fraction
was reduced to 19 ± 4% that in unfractionated cells (both
means ± SE, n=10). For HbA cells,
Cl--dependent K+ influxes
in oxygenated low-density fractions were 2.7 ± 0.6-fold
(mean ± SE, n=6) larger than
those in unfractionated blood.
The O2 dependence of KCC in fractionated red
cells is shown in Fig. 2a
for HbS cells and in Fig. 2b
for HbA cells. As
in Fig. 1
, Cl--dependent
K+ influxes in unfractionated HbS cell samples
were similar in magnitude when measured in air or
N2 (Fig. 2a
). K+
influx in the low-density fraction, although larger in magnitude, was
also largely independent of PO2.
Figure 2a
presents activity of KCC in HbS cells after
stimulation by urea, but similar results were observed after
stimulation by H+ ions (data not shown).
Sensitivity of KCC to calyculin A was also investigated. For
low-density HbS cells and when combining results for stimulation by
H+ ions or urea, mean inhibition of KCC by
calyculin A (100 nM) was 80 ± 5% in air and 83 ± 10% in
N2 (means ± SE,
n=4).
|
The effect of PO2 on
K+ influxes in low-density HbA cells stimulated
by urea is shown in Fig. 2b
. As for unfractionated cells
(Fig. 1)
, the relationship between PO2
and Cl--dependent K+
influx was sigmoidal, with flux increasing with
PO2. Peak influxes were observed by
80 mmHg whereas PO2 required for
half-maximal activation was 29 ± 2 (urea) and 37 ± 3
(H+ ions/swelling) mmHg (means ±
SE, n=3). In N2,
Cl--dependent K+ influxes
were low: 14 ± 2% or 15 ± 5% (means ±
SE, n=5) measured at
PO2 of 100 mmHg for urea or
H+ ion/swelling stimulation.
Effect of 12C79 on O2 saturation and sickling
The next series of experiments was designed to test the hypothesis
that HbS polymerization is involved in the abnormal
O2 response of KCC in HbS cells. We used the
substituted benzaldehyde 12C79 (44)
to stabilize HbS in
the oxy conformation and thereby reduce HbS polymerization. The effect
of 12C79 on the O2 saturation curve of HbS cells
is shown in Fig. 3a
. In its presence, the relationship between
O2 saturation and
PO2 was shifted toward lower
PO2s. The
PO2 required for half-maximal
O2 saturation decreased considerably (Table 1
), indicative of a marked increase in O2 affinity.
Since polymers of deoxygenated HbS are responsible for distorting the
red cell shape into the sickled appearance, sickling represents a
direct measure of polymerization. We therefore investigated the effect
of 12C79 on the O2 dependence of sickling. In the
presence of 12C79, sickling was also shifted toward significantly lower
PO2s (Fig. 3b
, Table 1
).
|
|
Effect of 12C79 on Psickle
The nonselective cation channel (Psickle)
activated stochastically upon deoxygenation (43)
is also
associated with HbS polymerization. We used
Cl--independent K+ influx
as a measure of its activity. This component of
K+ influx was increased by deoxygenation
(Fig. 4a
). Upon addition of 12C79, activation of
Cl--independent K+
influxes by deoxygenation was shifted to lower
PO2s. In both untreated HbS cells and
in those treated with 12C79, the PO2s
required for half-maximal activation of
Cl--independent K+
influxes were similar to those required for half-maximal saturation of
HbS with O2 (Table 1)
. Figure 4b
shows
the correlation between sickling and activity of
Cl--independent K+
influxes, which was significant (r2=0.92,
P<0.003).
Effect of 12C79 on KCC activity
We then examined the effects of 12C79 on the activity of KCC,
measured as Cl--dependent
K+ influx. We concentrated on the
PO2 range over which the
O2 dependence of KCC differs markedly when
comparing HbA and HbS cells: at low
PO2s, decreasing from 40 to 0 mmHg,
KCC in HbA red cells is progressively inhibited; that in HbS cells is
progressively stimulated (Fig. 1)
. In untreated HbS cells, stimulation
of KCC at low PO2s was half-maximal at
a PO2, similar to that required for
half-maximal O2 saturation of HbS (Table 1)
. In
the presence of 12C79, several changes are apparent (Fig. 5a
; Table 1
). First, from
PO2s of 40 to 100 mmHg, inactivation
of KCC was shifted slightly toward lower
PO2s. Second, inhibition of KCC
activity at 40 mmHg was less marked. Third, the low
PO2 stimulation (between 0 and 40
mmHg) of KCC was shifted significantly toward lower
PO2s (Table 1)
. As for
Psickle, the PO2
required for half-maximal stimulation of this component of KCC was also
similar to that required for half-maximal O2
saturation and cell sickling (Table 1)
. The relationship between
activity of KCC at low PO2s and
sickling correlated significantly (Fig. 5b
;
r2=0.87, P<0.001). Finally, we
examined the relationship between Cl--dependent
K+ influxes (via KCC) and
Cl--independent ones at
PO2s of
40 mmHg (Fig. 5c
). This also showed a significant correlation
(r2=0.77, P<0.01) between
K+ influx through the two pathways. Thus, all
four parameters measured in Table 1
showed a similar
O2 dependence under control conditions or after
treatment with 12C79.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A thorough characterization of cation transport in HbS cells is
directly relevant to understanding the pathophysiology of SCD because
of its contribution to dehydration and sickling. Three pathwaysKCC,
the Gardos channel, and Psickleare involved
(reviewed in refs 51
, 52
). Two of these transport pathways
are O2 sensitive. First,
Psickle opens stochastically upon deoxygenation,
probably subsequent to HbS polymerization (43
, 52
53
54)
.
Second, KCC activity in HbA red cells (and those from a number of other
vertebrate species (reviewed by Gibson et al., ref 34
), is
O2 dependent [e.g., trout (35
, 36)
,
horse (55)
, sheep (38)
, human HbA
(39)
]. KCC in HbS cells, however, has an abnormal
O2 response, remaining active at low
PO2s(39)
. These findings
are important because red cells will encounter H+
ions predominantly in active muscle beds or ischemic tissues and urea
in the renal medulla, all relatively hypoxic areas of the circulation.
The abnormal O2 dependence of HbS cell KCC
enables it to respond to these stimuli (32
, 39)
despite
the hypoxia and thereby mediate inappropriate and deleterious cell
dehydration. In addition, it will enable stimulation of KCC by
intracellular acidification due to K+ efflux
after activation of the Gardos channel (56)
, an event that
occurs only in deoxygenated HbS cells. In this paper, we have
investigated the O2 dependence of
K+ transport in red cells in an attempt to
uncover the mechanism responsible for the abnormal
O2 dependence of KCC in HbS cells.
The activity of KCC is highest in young mammalian red cells, decreasing
as the cells mature (25)
. In unfractionated HbA cells, the
activity of KCC is very low and stimulation by physiological factors
such as H+ ions and swelling is small
(26)
. The transporter is present, however, and its
activity can be markedly stimulated pharmacologically, e.g., by
treatment with N-ethylmaleimide or staurosporine or by
application of high hydrostatic pressure (8
, 57
, 58)
. It
is probable that part of the necessary signaling cascade is lost as
cells mature rather than the transporter per se. When HbA
cells are density fractionated, the low-density fraction of HbA cells,
representing the youngest subpopulation, is enriched for KCC activity
and exhibits greater responses to swelling and other stimuli than
unfractionated cells (26
, 58
, 59)
. Because of their
decreased life span, HbS cells represent a younger average population
than HbA red cells. As for HbA cells, most KCC activity is found in
cells from the lowest density fraction (21
, 27
, 42
, 58
59
60
61)
(although not all of the youngest cells are found in
this fraction because some will have undergone rapid fast-track
dehydration (21
, 42)
. Young red cells could have different
O2 responses from mature red cells, thus
accounting for the unusual behavior of KCC in HbS cells. We found,
however, that low-density HbA red cells exhibited a cotransporter
activity that was completely inhibited at low
PO2s, like that in unfractionated HbA
red cells. Stimulation by urea or H+ ions and
swelling was inhibited at low PO2s.
KCC activity in low-density HbS cells also retained the features
observed in unfractionated samples, remaining highly active at low
PO2s. These findings imply that the
abnormal O2 response of KCC in HbS cells is not
confined to a particular subfraction separable by density.
The ability of HbS to form polymers represents another obvious
difference between HbS and HbA cells (2
, 51)
. HbS
polymerization has several consequences: membrane distortion and
damage, sequestration of a large proportion of cell water, significant
metabolic effects and changes in membrane permeability, including
increased cation permeability via Psickle
(2
, 52
, 53)
. We used the substituted benzaldehyde 12C79 to
increase O2 affinity and thereby inhibit polymer
formation (44)
. Cl--independent
K+ influx, which in HbA cells is unaffected by
12C79 (63)
, was taken as a measure of
Psickle. With sufficient
Ca2+ entry via Psickle,
Cl--independent K+
transport would also occur via the Gardos channel; however, the present
experiments were carried out in the nominal absence of extracellular
Ca2+. Under the conditions of the present
experiments (15 min deoxygenation), addition of
Ca2+ (2.5 mM) or EGTA (100 µM) to the nominally
Ca2+-free MBS or addition of clotrimazole (10
µM) did not affect results (data not shown), suggesting that the
Gardos channel remained quiescent. While this may appear to suggest a
lack of deoxygenation-induced Ca2+ permeability
incompatible with the properties of Psickle, it
is not a unique finding. Joiner and colleagues (22
, 62)
have shown that measurable transport via the Gardos channel is not
always observed in unfractionated HbS cells upon deoxygenation. They
suggest that most activity resides in a small subpopulation of HbS
cells (perhaps those with least Ca2+ pump
activity) or that experimental conditions (for example, duration of
deoxygenation, which in some cases may be several hours) are critical
to allow sufficient Ca2+ entry via
Psickle. In an additional set of experiments in
which cells were deoxygenated in the presence of 2.5 mM
Ca2+ for 60 min, we did observe activation of a
Ca2+-dependent, clotrimazole-sensitive component.
We confirm that Cl--independent
K+ influxes were stimulated as
PO2 was reduced, as expected for
mediation via Psickle. In control HbS cells,
O2-dependence was similar to that in a previous
report that involved a different method (passive
K+ and Na+ fluxes) to
monitor Psickle (22)
. Upon addition
of 12C79, the stimulation of Cl--independent
K+ influxes occurred at lower
PO2s, so that in both control cells
and those treated with 12C79, the PO2s
required for half-maximal activation of
Cl--independent K+ influx
were similar to those required for half-maximal saturation of HbS with
O2 and half-maximal sickling (Table 1)
.
Percentage sickling was significantly correlated with activity of the
Cl--independent K+
pathway, again consistent with mediation via
Psickle. These findings are fully consistent with
activation of Psickle by HbS polymerization.
The O2 dependence of
Cl--dependent K+ transport
pathway (usually taken as via KCC) was also altered by 12C79. As for
the Cl--independent flux, the
PO2 required for half-maximal
stimulation (P50) of
Cl--dependent K+ transport
at low PO2s (040 mmHg) was also
similar to that required for half-maximal O2
saturation and half-maximal sickling (Table 1)
.
Cl--dependent K+ influxes
correlated significantly with sickling and with
Cl--independent influxes (Fig. 5b
, c
). These correlations may indicate a common underlying mechanism
involved in the activation of the two transport pathways. Although the
existence of parallel transduction pathways is a possibility, a role
for the O2 saturation of Hb is suggested by the
similarities in P50s and also argues against a
role for other heme-containing proteins. Taken together, our findings
suggest that the stimulation of KCC in HbS cells at low
PO2s, like sickling and activation of
Psickle, is also caused by HbS deoxygenation.
They may indicate a role for HbS polymerization.
Psickle may open subsequent to membrane
distortion by HbS polymers, and the same mechanism could account for
stimulation of KCC. In many cells, KCC mediates volume regulatory
decrease (RVD); in these responses, it is stimulated by cell swelling
(64)
. It is conceivable that distortion of the red cell
membrane by HbS polymers may activate KCC via this pathway. An
intriguing alternative possibility is that loss of soluble HbS into
polymers reduces macromolecular crowding (65)
, thereby
reducing the set point volume of the cell and activating RVD mechanisms
(C. H. Joiner, personal communication). The transporter is also
controlled by protein phosphorylation involving a cascade of, as yet,
unidentified regulatory kinase and phosphatase enzymes (66
, 67)
. The function of these may be subverted by polymerization of
HbS, although it is important to note that HbS cell KCC retains its
sensitivity to calyculin A at low
PO2s. Finally, the interaction of Hb
with other membrane-bound proteins, notably band 3, has been implicated
in the response of membrane transporters to O2
(reviewed in ref 68
). The abnormal
O2 dependence of HbS cell KCC may follow from the
altered behavior of HbS at this site.
Entrainment of KCC activity with HbS deoxygenation and polymerization
represents a novel hypothesis and would provide a further mechanism to
add to the other detrimental features of HbS cell pathophysiology (see
Fig. 6
for a model). Once cells start to sickle, stimulation of KCC would
mediate further solute loss, raising [HbS] and thus promoting
polymerization. These events not only represent positive feedback
contributing to the marked instability of HbS cells, but also indicate
future chemotherapeutic strategies (as presented schematically in Fig. 6
). For example, although it is difficult to achieve sufficiently high
levels of transport inhibitors to abrogate completely the individual
transport pathways, combination therapy with low doses of left
shift reagents, coupled with KCC and/or Gardos channel inhibitors,
may be tolerated clinically and act synergistically to stabilize sickle
volume and prevent the development of sickle cell crises.
|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Received for publication April 5, 2000.
Revision received August 11, 2000.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. A. Browning, H. M. Staines, H. C. Robinson, T. Powell, J. C. Ellory, and J. S. Gibson The effect of deoxygenation on whole-cell conductance of red blood cells from healthy individuals and patients with sickle cell disease Blood, March 15, 2007; 109(6): 2622 - 2629. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. L. Lew and R. M. Bookchin Ion Transport Pathology in the Mechanism of Sickle Cell Dehydration Physiol Rev, January 1, 2005; 85(1): 179 - 200. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. L. Lew, Z. Etzion, and R. M. Bookchin Dehydration response of sickle cells to sickling-induced Ca++ permeabilization Blood, April 1, 2002; 99(7): 2578 - 2585. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||