|
|
||||||||
Cell Biology and Metabolism Branch, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland, USA
1Correspondence: Cell Biology and Metabolism Branch, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Building 18T, Room 101, 18 Library Dr., Bethesda, MD 20892, USA. E-mail: jlippin{at}helix.nih.gov
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell biologists have made significant progress in elucidating the
biochemical requirements for secretory transport and the role of
transport intermediates (1
, 2)
. Less understood are the
morphological and kinetic properties of secretory traffic, including
how transport intermediates are formed and their path and fate during
transport. In addition, it is not clear how long cargo resides in a
particular compartment and the rate of cargo influx and efflux out of a
given compartment. This lack of understanding is largely because of the
inherent limitations of traditional approaches. For example,
biochemical assays using either in vitro or permeabilized
systems (3
, 4)
often have difficulty identifying and/or
characterizing intermediate steps because the amount of cargo carried
by transport intermediates within the secretory pathway is usually
quite small. Immunofluorescence and electron microscopy approaches,
which can be used to identify carriers, provide only static snapshots
of cells and therefore are unable to reveal the origin/fate of
transport intermediates and their dynamic properties.
A recent technique that overcomes many of the limitations inherent in
studies of in vitro or fixed specimens exploits the
intrinsic fluorescence of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a tag
for the production of fusion proteins (5)
. GFP fusion
proteins are easily expressed and visualized within living cells. They
are remarkably photostable to repetitive imaging using low illumination
levels and, in many cases, do not perturb normal trafficking or
function of the parent protein (6
, 7)
. They also can be
quantitated by correlating their fluorescence to a known standard
solution of GFP molecules (8
, 9)
. It is not surprising,
therefore, that GFP fusion proteins have been used as fluorescent
reporters in a wide variety of applications in living cells, including
time-lapse imaging studies to follow changes in protein distribution
(10
, 11)
, quantitative imaging experiments to measure the
amount of protein localized at a particular site (12
, 13)
,
and biophysical assays such as photobleaching to measure protein
mobility (14)
.
To study protein trafficking through the secretory pathway, we have
used a fusion protein where GFP was attached to the temperature
sensitive protein known as ts045 VSVG from vesicular stomatitis virus
(11)
. The ts045 VSVG protein is a type I transmembrane
protein that has been widely used for studying secretory membrane
traffic because it contains a mutation that leads to its reversible
misfolding and retention in the ER at 40°C (15
16
17
18
19)
. On
temperature reduction (e.g., to 32°C) the protein folds correctly and
is exported out of the ER and through the secretory pathway as a
synchronous pool. This property makes ts045 VSVG an ideal tool for
following protein traffic within cells. Addition of the GFP tag to the
cytoplasmic tail of ts045 VSVG did not alter either the folding or
transport properties of this protein (11
, 19)
. Recently,
GFP-tagged ts045 VSVG (VSVG-GFP) was used to visualize ER-to-Golgi
traffic in living cells (11
, 19)
. Release from the 40°C
temperature block by shifting to 32°C resulted in the ER-localized
chimera first concentrating in large, pleiomorphic pre-Golgi structures
(known as the intermediate compartment) scattered throughout the
cytoplasm. These structures, rather than small vesicles, then
translocated as units along microtubules to the Golgi complex. Because
these studies revealed that pre-Golgi structures are large, complex
structures that deliver cargo directly to the Golgi complex, they have
provided valuable insight into the functioning of the early secretory
pathway.
Here, we describe results using VSVG-GFP to characterize the transport
intermediates involved in membrane traffic from the Golgi complex to
the plasma membrane (13)
. We address how such structures
bud off from the Golgi complex, how they translocate through the
cytoplasm, and how they fuse with the plasma membrane. We also present
findings from kinetic modeling of VSVG-GFP transport data that reveal
how long VSVG-GFP cargo resides within the Golgi complex and its rate
of influx and efflux out of this compartment (13)
.
| GOLGI-TO-PLASMA MEMBRANE TRANSPORT OF VSVG-GFP |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The Golgi-derived tubules were not an artifact of VSVG-GFP expression,
because they were observed at both high and low expression levels of
VSVG-GFP and in diverse cell types. Indeed, previous time-lapse imaging
studies of living cells labeled with NBD-ceramide have revealed
numerous tubule processes extending out of Golgi elements
(20)
, while electron microscopy studies have commonly
found tubules emerging out of the trans face of the Golgi
complex (21
22
23)
. These observations, together with our
own, suggest that tubule growth and detachment are an important
mechanism for membrane export from the Golgi complex.
To further characterize the membrane tubules involved in Golgi export
of VSVG-GFP, double-labeling experiments were performed with antibodies
to peripheral membrane proteins of the Golgi and trans-Golgi
network (TGN). These included the coat protein, ß-COP
(24)
, and the adaptor complexes, AP1 and AP3
(25)
. No colocalization of these proteins with
VSVG-GFP-containing tubule elements was observed even though
significant overlap in the distribution of these proteins and VSVG-GFP
occurred in the Golgi body. This suggested that these proteins are not
directly involved in the formation of VSVG-GFP-containing tubules.
Whether or not other peripheral protein complexes will be identified
that regulate the formation and/or function of these tubules remains to
be elucidated. However, alternative mechanisms for the budding of these
structures to those based simply on coat recruitment and envelopment
are possible. Recent ideas involving lipid based sorting at the TGN
(26)
provide a potential explanation for how sorting of
VSVG-GFP into specific membrane domains might be coupled to tubule
budding.
Factors underlying the formation and detachment of Golgi tubules
containing VSVG-GFP were investigated in cells treated with nocodazole,
cytochalasin-B (cyto-B), or aluminum fluoride (AlF) (13)
.
Depolymerization of microtubules with nocodazole did not significantly
affect export of VSVG-GFP from the Golgi complex. This implied that the
tubules involved in Golgi export do not require microtubules to form or
detach from the Golgi complex (although microtubules are important for
the peripheral extension and translocation of these structures, as
discussed below). Treatment of cells with cyto-B, which depolymerizes
the actin cytoskeleton, in contrast, led to a delay of VSVG-GFP egress
from the Golgi complex. This implied that actin-based cytoskeletal
elements facilitate protein export from the Golgi complex as suggested
previously (27
, 28)
. The fact that Golgi-derived tubules
that formed in cyto-B-treated cells were significantly longer than in
untreated cells further suggested that actin-based elements could be
involved in the detachment of these transport intermediates. Treatment
of cells with AlF, which persistently activates heterotrimeric G
proteins, abolished all export of VSVG-GFP from the Golgi complex. This
suggested that AlF-sensitive components underlie Golgi protein export.
After detaching from the Golgi complex, tubule elements containing
VSVG-GFP typically moved out to the cell periphery and underwent
dramatic shape changes during transport. In confocal sections captured
at high speed, we observed these structures bifurcating, extending, and
retracting during movement. Their motion was saltatory and occurred at
maximal speeds of 2.7 µM/s. Treatment of cells with nocodazole
inhibited this movement, suggesting that the post-Golgi carriers (PGCs)
moved along microtubule tracks. These findings are similar to those
obtained from other studies examining transport of secretory cargo to
the cell surface (10
, 29)
. In those studies, as well as
our own, the net movement of post-Golgi structures was outward from the
Golgi region to the cell periphery. This suggested the involvement of a
plus end-directed microtubule motor protein (e.g., kinesin-like).
We found that PGCs enriched in VSVG-GFP could deliver their cargo to the cell surface in the absence of microtubules. A likely explanation for this type of delivery is via random diffusion of PGCs and their fusion with nearby plasma membrane sites. This is because the cells used in our experiments (i.e., COS) were flat with a distance of only a few micrometers between Golgi elements/PGCs and the plasma membrane.
PGCs enriched with VSVG-GFP were large and carried significant amounts
of cargo. We found that an average-sized PGC occupied an area of 1.3
µM2 corresponding to 32 pixels (with each pixel 0.2 x 0.2 µM). In contrast, a 100 nm fluorescent bead observed at the
same magnification and imaging conditions occupied a single bright
pixel. In a cell expressing ~20 million VSVG-GFP molecules, we
calculated that ~10,000 VSVG-GFP molecules were carried by a single
PGC at peak VSVG-GFP flux out of the Golgi complex (based on conversion
of VSVG-GFP fluorescence with fluorescence from a known standard
solution of GFP). For comparison, a 100 nm vesicle could carry no more
than 200 membrane proteins when maximally packed in a bilayer
(30)
. PGCs remained as large structures throughout their
short lifetime, which we calculated to be 3.8 min on average. During
transport, we found that PGCs never intersected with other
intracellular transport pathways.
Fusion of PGCs with the plasma membrane in COS cells expressing
VSVG-GFP was studied using an intensified video camera system to
continuously collect images. After docking at the plasma membrane for
10 s, PGCs fused with this surface. After fusion, dispersal of
VSVG-GFP fluorescence across the plasma membrane was rapid (i.e.,
2 s). This indicated VSVG-GFP was highly mobile on the plasma
membrane. The fact that the entire VSVG-GFP content of a PGC dispersed
on fusion with the plasma membrane indicated that PGCs were a single,
continuous structure rather than a chain or cluster of vesicles.
These findings suggest that Golgi-to-plasma membrane traffic is mediated by large tubulovesicular structures (i.e., PGCs) rather than by small vesicles. These structures bud as entire domains from the Golgi complex and move along microtubules without intersecting other pathways before fusing with the plasma membrane. They thus represent a unique intracellular transport organelle that conveys protein cargo from the Golgi complex directly to the plasma membrane. Future work needs to address how proteins sort into these structures, what regulates their formation, and how they move along microtubule tracks.
| QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS AND KINETIC MODELING OF SECRETORY TRANSPORT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fitting the time course data to our trafficking model did not require a
changing rate constant as the concentration of VSVG-GFP in various
compartments went from high (early in the experiment) to low (late in
the experiment). Rather, we found that a series of first order rate
laws connecting the ER, Golgi complex, and plasma membrane was
sufficient to accurately account for the data, indicating that
secretory transport machinery was never saturated during VSVG-GFP
transport. This allowed us to calculate VSVG-GFP flux (i.e., molecules
per second) into and out of the Golgi complex and delivery to the
plasma membrane in individual cells. For ER-to-Golgi transport of
VSVG-GFP, the mean rate constant was 2.8%/min; for Golgi-to-plasma
membrane transport it was 3.0%/min; and for transport from the plasma
membrane to a degradative site it was 0.25%/min (see Fig. 1D
). For a cell containing ~2 x
107 VSVG-GFP molecules, the rate constants
predicted a peak ER-to-Golgi flux of 7,000 molecules per second (1520
min after shifting to permissive temperature), a peak Golgi-to-plasma
membrane flux of 4,000 molecules per second (at 4045 min), and a peak
plasma membrane to lysosome flux of 700 molecules per second (at
125150 min). A VSVG-GFP molecule was found to spend on average about
the same time in the Golgi complex as in the ER compartment; mean
residence time was ~40 min for each. In contrast, mean residence time
in the plasma membrane and its associated membranes before degradation
was ~700 min. These transport rates are the first to be reported for
a specific protein population within single living cells.
Previous kinetic measurements of the secretory pathway have used
radiolabeled amino acid pulse-chase kinetics combined with cell
fractionation and immunoprecipitation (31
32
33)
. These
measurements are significantly less precise than the above estimated
values using GFP imaging methods for several reasons. First,
traditional biochemical analyses typically use only 610 data points
(because cell fractionation is so labor intensive), and each point
represents the average value from thousands of different cells. In
contrast, our sampling involves hundreds of data points collected from
the same cell. Second, our Golgi "fraction" (i.e., a spatial site
within a single cell) is exceptionally well-defined in contrast to
biochemical isolation of Golgi fractions from gradients where
contamination with other organelle fractions is unavoidable.
We believe that kinetic analysis of secretory trafficking using GFP imaging techniques can be used to study much more complex transient situations, such as physiological or pharmacological perturbations or even cell-cycle-induced changes in protein trafficking pathways, that simply cannot be approached using traditional steady-state tracer kinetic methods. We have found, for example, that in cells treated with cyto-B, which disrupts the actin cytoskeleton, there is a significant decrease in the Golgi exit rate constant and an increase in the rate of internalization of VSVG-GFP from the cell surface. These changes in rate constant for VSVG-GFP trafficking suggest that there are regulatory changes in Golgi export mechanisms and plasma membrane trafficking on disruption of the actin cytoskeleton.
The fact that linear rate laws could summarize the diverse trafficking
events occurring between the ER and Golgi, and between the Golgi and
plasma membrane, suggests that within each of these sets of events, the
transport processes were effectively characterized by a single
rate-limiting step and that neither the identity nor quantitative
features of this rate-limiting step was perturbed by VSVG-GFP
trafficking. With additional imaging approaches, we anticipate that it
will be possible to refine our model of VSVG-GFP trafficking to
characterize specific pathways in more detail. For example, we have
used photobleaching combined with high-resolution imaging to study the
role of transport intermediates involved in Golgi-to-plasma membrane
trafficking (13)
. By kinetically modeling the data, we
were able to calculate the fraction of total Golgi-to-cell surface
transport of VSVG-GFP that occurs by large post-Golgi structures rather
than small vesicles, and to estimate the lifetime of these structures
within cells.
In conclusion, these studies demonstrate that GFP imaging methods combined with computational analysis provide a new approach for dissecting the control and regulation of the secretory pathway in single, intact, living cells. Numerous questions relevant to the regulation and functioning of the secretory pathway can thereby be addressed, providing insight into how molecular machinery functions on a system-wide basis within secretory membranes of living cells.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. Kockx, W. Jessup, and L. Kritharides Regulation of Endogenous Apolipoprotein E Secretion by Macrophages Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., June 1, 2008; 28(6): 1060 - 1067. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Dukhovny, A. Papadopulos, and K. Hirschberg Quantitative live-cell analysis of microtubule-uncoupled cargo-protein sorting in the ER J. Cell Sci., March 15, 2008; 121(6): 865 - 876. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
O. Beske, M. Reichelt, M. P. Taylor, K. Kirkegaard, and R. Andino Poliovirus infection blocks ERGIC-to-Golgi trafficking and induces microtubule-dependent disruption of the Golgi complex J. Cell Sci., September 15, 2007; 120(18): 3207 - 3218. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. B. Saenz, T. A. Doggett, and D. B. Haslam Identification and Characterization of Small Molecules That Inhibit Intracellular Toxin Transport Infect. Immun., September 1, 2007; 75(9): 4552 - 4561. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |